Abstract:
Simulation-based learning (SBL) in healthcare is a key teaching strategy in nursing education but often induces anxiety, which can increase cognitive load and hinder learning. Evidence suggests mindfulness-based activities (MBAs) reduce anxiety and cognitive load, potentially improving memory retention and knowledge application. This study explored the effect of MBAs on anxiety and cognitive load during SBL for prelicensure nursing students.
Junior-level Bachelor of Science in Nursing (BSN) students participating in SBL in a Clinical Nursing Foundations (CNF) course were randomly assigned to a control or intervention group. Both groups received a standardized prebrief aligned with the Healthcare Simulation Standards of Best Practice. The intervention group also received a 2-minute, 44-second scripted mindfulness body scan (MBA). Pre-simulation state anxiety was assessed using the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory (STAI) before and after the prebrief. Post-simulation cognitive load was measured via the NASA Task Load Index (NASA TLX). Results were compared to assess the MBA’s impact on anxiety and cognitive load, and the relationship between anxiety and cognitive load was analyzed.
The MBA significantly reduced pre-simulation state anxiety in the intervention group compared to the control group (t(167)=3.805, p<0.001, Cohen’s d=0.594). Paired t-tests within the intervention group showed a large reduction in anxiety from baseline (t(87)=8.992, p<0.001, Cohen’s d=0.959), while no significant change occurred in the control group. Although global cognitive load scores on the NASA TLX did not differ significantly between groups, frustration—a subscale of the NASA TLX—was significantly lower in the intervention group (t(163)=2.170, p=0.031). In the control group, anxiety correlated positively with cognitive load (r=0.411, p=0.002), but no meaningful correlation appeared in the intervention group.
Integrating MBAs into SBL prebriefing effectively reduces pre-simulation anxiety, fostering an emotionally supportive learning environment. While overall cognitive load was unaffected, reduced frustration highlights potential benefits for learning outcomes. The positive relationship between anxiety and cognitive load in the control group underscores the need to manage anxiety to optimize learning. This study supports MBAs as a simple, practical strategy to enhance the SBL experience for prelicensure nursing students.
Learning Objectives:
- Describe the impact of a brief mindfulness-based activity on anxiety and cognitive load among our learners in simulation.
- Discuss the relationship between anxiety and cognitive load in simulation-based learning, highlighting the benefits of integrating mindfulness.
- Identify a practical strategy for implementing a mindfulness activity into prebriefing to promote psychological safety during simulation for our learners.